I've seen this list floating around Pinterest, and I thought I'd finally sit down and listen to every song. As a whole, I really like it. It's a folky-hipster collection of songs that play well together. There are a few songs I'm not crazy about, but overall, it's pretty great.
There are links to each song below, if you don't want to go to the trouble of looking up every song. I tried, as best as I could, to like to the official music videos.
I marked my favourite ones with asterisks. I'd love to hear which ones you like (or don't), and whether there's any songs you'd add to the list.
Down in the Valley by The Head and the Heart*
Spanish Saharah by Foals
Winter Winds by Mumford and Sons*
The Only Living Boy in New York by Simon and Garfunkel
Welcome Home by Radical Face*
Here We Go Again by Angus & Julia Stone
The Sound of Settling by Death Cab for Cutie*
Lost in My Mind by The Head and the Heart
Changes by David Bowie
Stay Young (Go Dancing) by Death Cab for Cutie*
Amie by Pure Prairie League
Indian Summer by Beat Happening*
Blue Spotted Tails by Fleet Foxes
Seashell by Seabear
You Remind Me of Home by Ben Gibbard
Hotcha Girls by Ugly Casanova
Cats & Dogs by The Head and the Heart
If I Was a Baby by Ezra Furman & The Harpoons
Oliver James by Fleet Foxes
Take Me Home, Country Roads by John Denver